Rabbi David Walk, Education Director

Congregation Agudath Sholom | 301 Strawberry Hill Ave | Stamford, CT 06902 (203)-358-2200 www.agudathsholom.org

Tuesday, November 28, 2017

Walk Article



Rabbi David Walk


Ya'akov Avinu spent big chunks of his life outside of Israel.  His last 17 years were, of course, spent in Egypt, and he stayed in Padan Aram for a number of decades.  The exact number of decades (2 or 4) is a debate, depending upon your choice of commentary.  With that in mind, I feel less guilty about spending the last 16 years in the Diaspora.  The minor difference is that God gave Ya'akov assurances about his sojourns in the outside world while I did it to myself.  It's of interest, at least to me, how God was so caring before each journey.  On his way to Padan Aram, God, speaking from atop the Ladder said, 'Notice I will protect wherever you go, and return you to this land (Genesis 32:15)', and before the descent to Egypt, 'Do not be afraid of going down to Egypt...I will go down with you to Egypt, and I will also bring you up (46:3-4).'  On the other hand, when it was time to return, God just said, 'Now, arise, go forth from this land and return to the land of your birth (31:13).'  How come no guarantees?  Well, that's this week's assignment.

Our parsha begins with a famous scene, Ya'akov sends emissaries to Esav with the following instructions:  So shall you say to my master to Esav, 'Thus said your servant Ya'akov:  I have sojourned with Lavan, and I have tarried until now…' (32:5).  There's a lot to unpack in that little speech.  Let's begin at the end.  What's this business about 'tarried' (Hebrew:  icher)?  Let's go for simple.  He stayed until God told him to return.  But God could have told him to return home either because it was no longer good for him in Padan Aram with his nasty father-in-law or, perhaps, the coast was clear back in Canaan, Esav had calmed down after 20 or 40 years.  I like the second approach, for it begins to answer our question about why no promises of safety with the instructions to go back home.

It's the first phrase of the message which gets all the famous attention.  What does it mean 'I sojourned with Lavan'? Rashi gives two answers.  The first is:  I sojourned means that I remained a nobody, so that blessing from Dad which bothered you so much never came true.  Okay.  The second is based on a well-known gematria.  The numerical value of the Hebrew word garti (meaning: I sojourned) is 613.  Clearly, this is a reference to pomegranates.  No, it's not.  That's the number of mitzvot in the Torah.  Which means that Ya'akov is telling Esav that he can't harm him because he has remained faithful to Torah and mitzvot throughout his stay with Lavan.  I mean, we all know that righteous Jews have been immune from persecution and danger throughout history.  Hmm.  In this particular circumstance, there is another dynamic at work.  Ya'akov may be thinking that God didn't give him promises of safety, because he had acquired his own shield through his faithfulness to their tradition.

There's one more text which unnerves the commentaries.  After being told that Esav was, indeed, on the way to a reunion, but he was coming with an army of 400.  Ya'akov didn't assume that this was an honor guard.  Then the verse records:  Ya'akov became very frightened and was distressed (verse 8).  Why this excessive concern?  Ya'akov has had assurances of safety from God, but he still might be afraid of an army of this size, perhaps he has committed a sin and has lost some of his merit.  Rashi records the most famous approach to the problem:  He's afraid that he might be killed; he was 'distressed' that he might have to kill others.  This sounds like the statement of Golda Meir OB"M, 'We can forgive the Egyptians for killing our children, but we can never forgive them making our children killers.'  An admirable and, I believe, Jewish reaction.

But, perhaps, we can answer this question and provide a possible solution to our original problem.  Why didn't God give Ya'akov as strong a promise of protection when coming back to Israel as he got when leaving Israel, both for Padan Aram and Egypt?  Simple, God is telling Ya'akov that, in general, Jews don't need as much Divine protection and intervention in Israel, because this is our natural habitat.  If we bring penguins (don't you just love penguins) to a zoo in a hot climate we must carefully arrange for their safety.  Israel is the natural habitat for Jewish souls, therefore, generally, we don't need special protection.  Sadly, that doesn't mean that we can't injure our innate ability to live in the Holy Land, through egregious misbehavior.  Many prophets have told us that when we behave like Sodom, we lose our normal affinity to the Promised Land.

Now, please, allow me to me to give my interpretation for this dilemma.  Ya'akov was afraid because Esav was approaching with 400 men.  That's reasonable.  Even in Israel we're not supposed to depend on miracles.  We still must do everything in our power to act responsibly and wisely.  But he was distressed and felt in tzarot, because this was Israel, the land promised to him through his allegiance to his father's and grandfather's belief system. This stuff wasn't supposed to happen here.  God gives him iron clad promises when he leaves Israel, because that's where he feels like a fish out of water, but not here.

In Israel, we feel a connection to the Land, which engenders a different mind-set.  There's more confidence and poise.  We feel at home.  In the play Camelot, King Arthur describes his kingdom as the best place for 'happy ever aftering'.  L'havdil, I think that's what our prophets meant when they've promised us time and time again, in many different ways, that 'a time will come when the great shofar will be blown and all those who were lost and expelled will return to worship God here.'  It's good to be home. 






Monday, November 27, 2017

CYBER MONDAY- Get YOUR ½ Price Subscription to The Jewish Week NOW